Both practices come from the same training system. The equipment is where they diverge, and the equipment changes what each exercise asks of your body. Mat Pilates uses your body weight as the only load. A reformer adds a spring-loaded carriage, which means variable resistance on every movement. That single addition reshapes most exercises in the system.
What is the difference between reformer and mat Pilates?
Mat Pilates works through body weight on a floor mat. A reformer adds a spring system attached to a carriage: resistance that can resist a movement, assist it, or both, depending on the exercise and the spring setting.
Better Health Channel describes the reformer as "a moveable carriage that you push and pull along its tracks." The springs "provide variable resistance and continuous neuromuscular feedback." The carriage itself "provides support and also challenges balance."
Spring resistance increases as the spring stretches further. Heavier tension doesn't mean a harder exercise. In some movements, more tension means more resistance. In others, the spring supports part of your body weight and more tension reduces the demand on your muscles. A beginner and an advanced practitioner can do the same exercise on the same machine and both be loaded correctly, because the spring works in both directions.
The table below sets out the six main factors separating the two formats.
| Factor | Reformer | Mat |
|---|---|---|
| Resistance | Variable spring load; resists or assists depending on the exercise | Body weight only |
| Support | Carriage supports body weight and challenges balance | Floor surface |
| Variety | Same exercise, many spring load options | Rep count, tempo and position variation |
| Space | About 2.5 m of clear room length (models 244–256 cm); see how much space you need for a reformer | Any clear floor space |
| Equipment | A reformer | A mat |
| Cost of entry | A reformer | A mat |
For a full breakdown of how the machine works (springs, carriage, footbar, ropes and headrest), see our guide to what is reformer Pilates.
Which is better for beginners?
No research ranks one format above the other for someone new to Pilates. Both suit beginners when a qualified instructor guides them; our reformer Pilates for beginners guide covers the first session.
Better Health recommends consulting "a qualified and registered health, fitness or Pilates professional" before starting either practice. That recommendation applies broadly, not only if you have a known injury. For some groups (people returning to exercise after a long break, those with a recent surgery, pregnancy, heart condition, or musculoskeletal injury), Better Health recommends individual clearance before beginning.
If you plan to train at home on a reformer, studio classes or private sessions before your machine arrives give you the movement foundation the machine cannot provide on its own. A certified instructor can show you how the springs load each exercise and what a controlled carriage movement feels like, before you are the only one in the room.
Which builds more strength?
Two small randomised trials that directly compared the two formats found similar improvements across most outcomes. In one trial, the reformer group improved more on trunk flexor strength than the mat group.
Bulguroglu et al. (NeuroRehabilitation, 2017) randomised 38 people with multiple sclerosis to mat Pilates, reformer Pilates, or a control group. Both Pilates groups trained twice a week for eight weeks. Both groups improved on balance, functional mobility, core stability, fatigue severity and quality of life; the control group did not change. Outcomes between the two Pilates groups were similar across most measures; the reformer group improved more on trunk flexor strength. The authors concluded that "patients with MS have seen similar benefits in Reformer Pilates and Mat Pilates methods."
Çağlayan et al. (Reumatología Clínica, 2023) compared reformer Pilates with home mat Pilates in 28 women with fibromyalgia, twice a week for six weeks. Both groups improved across their primary measures; the authors found no statistically significant difference between the groups in delta values.
Both trials used clinical populations with small samples. No adequately sized trial comparing the two formats in healthy adults has been published. In the populations studied so far, both formats produce improvements and outcomes between them are largely similar, with one measured advantage in trunk flexor strength for the reformer.
Can you do both?
Yes. The trials in the section above compared both formats in the same studies, each as a complete practice in its own right. The fibromyalgia trial included a home mat Pilates arm specifically, and that group improved on their primary measures.
Practitioners often move between the two formats depending on access: a studio mat class when a reformer is not available, a home reformer session otherwise. Better Health suggests two or three sessions per week for either practice. Sessions in either format count toward that frequency.
The two practices load the same movements differently. The spring system adds resistance options that body weight alone cannot replicate; the mat asks for different kinds of control. Using both gives you more than either does alone.
Which suits a home practice?
A mat needs a clear floor and stores flat. A reformer needs about 2.5 m of clear room length and stays set up. Beyond those practical differences, the two formats suit a home setting in distinct ways.
Milaron's three reformer models measure 244–256 cm in length. With around 50 cm of clear space on each side, most spare bedrooms, garages and open living areas fit the machine comfortably. For exact dimensions and room-planning guidance, see how much space you need for a reformer.
Training at home without an instructor, the reformer gives you something a mat cannot: spring feedback. The springs provide "continuous neuromuscular feedback" throughout each movement. That feedback tells you when control has shifted in the exercise, before the session ends and you realise something felt off. On a mat, the floor gives no equivalent signal.
For spring variation as a training tool (adjusting resistance rather than adding repetitions), see our guide to springs on a Pilates reformer.
The Milaron Pilates Reformer runs on six German Piano Wire springs with a 5-year warranty on the frame. In-stock machines arrive within 7 days, free, Australia-wide. If you are weighing up models, our guide to the best Pilates reformers in Australia covers what to look for. You can also browse the full range.
Check with your GP or physiotherapist before starting a new exercise program, especially if you have an injury or condition.